Pick-n-Pull review

Pick-n-Pull is one of the largest self-service chains, with 44 US and 4 Canadian locations that the company says average over 1,200 cars and trucks each. It focuses on vehicles 7 or more years old, which suits owners of older cars who need affordable OEM parts. You check inventory online, pay a small admission fee, find the car and pull the part with your own tools. Prices are fixed and posted by location: at Little Rock an alternator costs $32.99 plus a $9.99 core deposit. Every part comes with a 30 day exchange, and on select parts such as alternators, starters, transmissions and engines you can add 12-month WarrantyPlus for 30% of the part price. Toolkit Rewards gives a $20 certificate at 350 points, and admissions earn points. Row52, a separate search site, now covers only Pick-n-Pull yards. The admission amount is not listed on the store pages we checked, so call your store if it matters.

Who it is for

DIY mechanics and small shops near its stores who want OEM parts at fixed prices.

Price

Small admission fee; fixed part prices, such as an alternator for $32.99 plus a $9.99 core deposit at Little Rock.

601 ALTERNATOR Car $32.99 $9.99
Quoted from the vendor pricing page on November 10, 2026.

Key features

• Online inventory check for each store, also searchable through Row52
• Fixed part pricing lists by location
• Computerized parts interchange system
• 30 day parts exchange policy
• 12-month WarrantyPlus for 30% of the part price on select parts

Strengths and weaknesses

• Strength: Stores average over 1,200 cars and trucks
• Strength: Fixed prices with no haggling
• Strength: Extended warranty available on major parts
• Weakness: Admission fee amount is not shown on the store pages we checked
• Weakness: Focus is on vehicles 7 or more years old
• Weakness: You pull parts yourself

Key facts

• Stores: 44 US and 4 Canadian locations
• Cars per store: Over 1,200 on average
• Exchange: 30 days with receipt
• Extended warranty: WarrantyPlus, 12 months for 30% of part price
• Rewards: Toolkit Rewards, $20 reward at 350 points

Where it ranks

Pick-n-Pull is No. 5 in our Best Websites for Used Car Parts verdict.