Noble Knight Games review

Noble Knight Games is the store to check when a game is out of print. Since 1997 it has run a buy, sell and trade model from Fitchburg, Wisconsin, and its about page says the catalog includes more than 300,000 unique products available for immediate shipment, with no placeholder listings for stock it does not have. Used items get a hands-on inspection and a grade under a published grading system, which matters when you are paying for a rare boxed game. If a title is not in stock, want lists and item alerts tell you when one comes in from a collection. Shipping is reasonable: Noble Knight Flat Rate never exceeds $9.95 in the contiguous US, and orders of $149 or more ship free on standard economy service. The tradeoffs are a busy catalog that is slower to browse than a mainstream store and economy delivery that can take up to 21 days in some areas.

Who it is for

Collectors hunting out-of-print or used board games and wargames in graded condition.

Price

Free to shop; flat rate shipping capped at $9.95, free from $149.

Noble Knight Flat Rate shipping will never exceed $9.95, no matter what or how much you order
Quoted from the vendor pricing page on November 10, 2026.

Key features

• More than 300,000 unique products listed as in stock
• Used items inspected and graded with a published grading system
• Sell or trade your collection by mail or in person
• Want lists and item alerts for titles not in stock
• Prices shown in USD, AUD, CAD, EUR, GBP or JPY

Strengths and weaknesses

• Strength: Best source here for out-of-print and hard-to-find games
• Strength: Flat rate shipping never exceeds $9.95 in the contiguous US
• Strength: Lists only items it physically has on hand
• Weakness: Free shipping needs $149, and only on economy shipping
• Weakness: Dense catalog takes longer to browse than mainstream stores
• Weakness: Economy shipping can take up to 21 days in some locations

Key facts

• Founded: 1997, Fitchburg, Wisconsin
• Catalog: More than 300,000 unique products
• Shipping: Flat rate capped at $9.95; free from $149 (contiguous US)
• Used games: Hands-on inspection and grading
• International: Ships worldwide

Where it ranks

Noble Knight Games is No. 5 in our Best Places to Buy Board Games Online verdict.